All posts Bidding strategy

Past performance when your firm has none: what still counts

No federal record gets a neutral rating, not a poor one. What evaluators can still credit: your people, subcontracts, joint ventures, state and commercial work.

An Offra card for Bidding strategy

Every firm that bids on federal work for the first time hits the same wall. The solicitation asks for three similar contracts from the last few years, and the firm has never held one. You need a record to win, and you need to win to get a record.

The rules are softer here than most first-time bidders assume, in two ways. A missing record is not scored as a bad one. And the record an evaluator may credit is wider than the contracts held in your firm's own name. Neither makes the wall go away, but together they tell you which bids are worth the work.

No record is not a bad record

The federal rule is short: an offeror with no record of relevant past performance, or whose record is not available, may not be evaluated favorably or unfavorably on past performance. Evaluators call it a neutral rating. The rewrite of the federal acquisition rules now under way kept that sentence word for word.

Neutral protects you from being marked down. It does not make you competitive, and how much it helps depends on how the buyer is choosing:

  • Lowest price, technically acceptable. Past performance, when it is evaluated at all, is pass or fail, with no comparison between offerors. A firm with no record cannot be failed for having none, so the cheapest acceptable offer can still be yours.
  • Best-value tradeoff. Here offerors are compared. A neutral rating sits next to competitors rated with substantial confidence, and the evaluators are allowed to pay more for that confidence. If past performance is weighted as heavily as the technical approach, neutral is a real handicap.
  • Sealed bids. An invitation for bids has no past-performance factor. The lowest responsive bid wins, provided the contracting officer finds the bidder responsible. If a small business is found not responsible, the decision goes to SBA, which can overrule it with a certificate of competency. RFP, RFQ, IFB: what each one is asking for covers the differences.

Read the evaluation section before you read anything else. It tells you which of the three you are in, and how much weight past performance carries against price.

The record that is not in your firm's name

The same rules list what evaluators should take into account beyond the offeror's own contracts. Most first-time bidders under-use every one of them.

Your people

Evaluators should consider information about key personnel who have relevant experience. A project manager who ran three similar jobs for a previous employer brings that record with them. Name the person, the contracts, the agency and the role they played, and propose them in the role the solicitation scores. A record attached to someone who will not work on the job does not count for much.

Predecessor companies

If your firm was formed from another business, or took one over, the predecessor's record can be considered. Explain the link plainly: what carried over, and who.

Subcontractors doing major or critical work

The record of a subcontractor that will perform major or critical aspects of the requirement can be considered too. The condition is real work. A well-known name listed for a sliver of the job adds little, and evaluators can see the workshare.

On bundled or consolidated contracts, the Small Business Act goes further for small business teams: the agency has to consider the past performance of each small business first-tier subcontractor on the team as the prime's own.

State, local and commercial work

A federal request for proposals that evaluates past performance has to give offerors the chance to list past or current contracts of every kind: federal, state and local government, and private sector. County road work, a hospital's renovation and a school district's IT contract all count, if they are similar in size, scope and complexity. Say why each one is similar. Evaluators judge relevance from what you write, and they will not do the comparison for you.

Joint ventures and mentor-protégé

A joint venture's own record is considered first. If it has none, the agency has to consider the record of each party to it. On a joint venture bidding work set aside for small business, the agency must consider the work each partner did on its own as well as the joint venture's.

The SBA mentor-protégé program goes furthest. On a joint venture between a protégé and its SBA-approved mentor, the agency may rely solely on the mentor's past performance. If it asks for some record from the protégé, it cannot hold the protégé to all the same criteria as other offerors, and the protégé's successful work on smaller contracts must be rated the same as the mentor's on larger ones. A small business that was part of a joint venture before can later use that joint venture's record if it has none of its own, provided it tells the contracting officer what it actually did.

Make the record you have easy to credit

Whatever you submit, the evaluator has to be able to credit it quickly.

  1. Match each reference to the work statement. One line on size, one on scope, one on complexity, each tied to the requirement.
  2. Give working contacts. A reference who cannot be reached is a reference the evaluator may skip. Warn your references that a call may come.
  3. Respect the window and the count. If the solicitation asks for contracts from the last three years, a five-year-old job may be excluded. If it asks for three, send three good ones rather than six thin ones.
  4. Use the buyer's form. Many solicitations supply a past-performance table or questionnaire. Fill that in. A brochure sent in its place may not count.

Building a federal record

The record evaluators trust most is CPARS, the government-wide system where agencies record contractor evaluations. An evaluation is required on contracts above the simplified acquisition threshold, on construction contracts of $900,000 or more, and on architect-engineer contracts of $45,000 or more. When one is ready, you get a notice and up to 14 days to comment or rebut. Use them: your comment is kept with the evaluation that later buyers read.

Below those thresholds, there is often no CPARS entry at all. Ask the contracting officer or the prime for a reference letter when a small job goes well.

The fastest route to a record is usually as a subcontractor to a firm that already has one. Ask the prime, before the work starts, whether it will act as a reference and fill in a past-performance questionnaire for you. A Sources Sought response is the other early move: it is where you tell a buyer that you exist, before the evaluation criteria are written.

When to pass

Pass when the evaluation is a best-value tradeoff, past performance carries as much weight as the technical approach, and none of the routes above gives you anything relevant. A neutral rating against incumbents with strong records rarely wins those, and the proposal costs the same either way. The better bid is often to the likely prime, as a subcontractor. The bid/no-bid call in twenty minutes puts this next to the other questions worth asking first.

In Offra, a bid's Past projects step writes one sheet per project from the projects in your knowledge base. When the buyer supplies its own form, the step sets the fields to copy beside it. It does not make up a project: what only your firm can supply is left as a marked blank, so you see the gap before the evaluator does.

Related reading: registered in SAM.gov is not one thing and what a set-aside actually excludes.

Ready when you are

Win more public tenders, with a fraction of the effort.

Upload your first tender and get a review-ready checklist of requirements, gaps and deadlines in minutes.

Free account: search every open tender, with the go/no-go on every notice for your first 14 days. Pay only for the bids you answer.